yes you`ll get a rattle because of the straight cut gears in the box,,, as soon as you put your foot on the clutch the gearbox gears basically stop turning,,, therefore the s/c gears stop chattering.
chattering away at idle with the foot off the clutch with a 6-speed dog box with s/c drop gear set is brain-draining
& yes the A+ gear-sets were produced to help keep noise at a lower level,,, different helical cut on the teeth specifically to help keep them quieter,,, but as the good Doc suggested they cannot be "Miss-matched
even if you tried you won`t get them to miss-match
also the A+ idler is a much larger diam shafts (either side) than the early A-series idler.
this goes with that at Susan