kirby wrote:
Theres no point in using the EDIS system at all anymore. Modern mega-squirt/jolt/whatever can drive coils directly and the best way is one coil per cylinder, do away with the leads entirely.
I believe all versions of Megajolt require an EDIS module, so no chance using coil on plug, unless you go wasted spark, but that seems a waste of time.
I run a Megasquirt 2 V3 and still run an EDIS, Why? I prefer having the coil drivers externally, I like the fact that EDIS has the limp home mode, It's in a rugged weatherproof package (so can be mounted in the engine bay) and I have a few on the shelf, so on the unlikley event that one blows up, 2 minutes unscrewing the EDIS and swapping it, Bit quicker than swapping the BIP373 coil drivers inside the megasquirt.
kirby wrote:
For whatever reason you still want to use the old EDIS system.
I would like to see some numbers on the excel coil, particularly the dwell angle as well as the resistance. Its not as simple as putting on any old coil.
Dwell angle is a bit of an old school expression, as it refers to distributor degrees, which is a bit hard to use if you don't have a distributor! Usually with modern computer controlled stuff it is expressed in milliseconds. The dwell time I used for the ford coil was the same as the excel coil as it is controlled by the EDIS module, not the MS/Megajolt, The EDIS knows no different what coil is attached to it, so it dwells the coil the same amount of time. I've had no problems with that, never missed under load and the coil never got hot. I know you can calculate dwell using the coil inductance, resistance and other things, but it's all a bit academic when you can't change it anyway.
Primary resistance? Can't remember, I do remeber checking it and thinking it was seemed close to the ford coil. I ended up taking the "suck it and see" approach.... I figured I have the excel coil, spare EDIS modules, whats the worst that could happen? A blown coil or a burnt out EDIS? Not a huge loss. Seemed to work out in the end anyway. Drove my car for about 2 years with it on there, even to Hay and back, never missed a beat.
kirby wrote:
All of those features are in a mega-whatever already, plus its a lot cheaper to replace a failed coil driver.
Ummm... I'm not sure what you're referring to with "Mega-whatever", but if its megajolt, yes you are correct, it does have all those features as it runs EDIS.
I don't really see any point for most mini owners to be running out and buying anything better than a megajolt if they just want to run it for ignition. Yes, Megasquirt 2 and 3 have lots of nifty features, but most are a bit pointless if your just running it for ignition only. Doubt you'd make any more power on a carb fed mini using Megasquirt 3 over Megajolt, and its less than half the price and half the complexity.
Andrew