1071 wrote:
Sorry guys but you're talking codswallop.
The flywheel does accumulate kinetic energy -
And, if you don't believe the physics, just point out one Japanese crotch rocket with a big iron flywheel to compensate for those torque deficient engines they run.
...
Cheers, Ian
most Jap cars have much "HEAVIER" flywheels than minis do (in general)
sorry but i think you have totally missed my point ,,, & i really do believe your point is that
"YOU" like light-flywheels,,, Man ,,, so do i... but not in a
small capacity "Road" motor
My point is,.,, """"SMALL CAPACITY A-SERIES ROAD MOTOR"""""
Nick (NG) started this thread about 100hp engines,,, but was talking(asking) about it for his """ROAD""" mini,,, & it`s a Stn Wagon... ---> not a lightweight race mini.
If what you say is sooo damn true Ian,,, then how`s about we take the flywheel out of the car alltogether,,,, (((( & I`ll Quote here---> """The Lighter The Better""" right Ian???
Lets just take the whole lot out yeah??? Just leave enough small diam to have some sort of tiny small diam clutch mech to make some grab & a flex-plate type "thing" simply for the starter ring gear ,,, Bugga all weight then ,,, almost none yeah???????????
The fact is that the poor little thing would Just """""STALL"""" every time you try to take off in first gear it would """STALL"""!!!!!!!!!!!!,.,,, so then you`d have to try & compensate for that "Lack of Torque" by
Attempting to multiply the """TORQUE""" factor by means of Massive gear reduction """WAY PAST""" 4:1 or maybe even 5:1 1st gear ratio to enable some form of
"""civilised""" take off the line without stalling...with little or very very light weight flywheel, the car would simply stall off the mark without reving the tits off it & slipping the clutch.
Yes it`s an exageration, but that`s my point,,,,
Motorbikes have very little flywheel,,, """"BECAUSE"""" there is very little total mass to move,,, the flywheel is "Weighted" according to the power of the engine, the weight of the entire vehicle, & the desired """USE""" of the vehicle... simple as that !!!!!!!
sorry but a 500million tonne ocean-liner (Big Motha Boat) actually does need a motha pharken flywheel,,, so does a huge motha phucken 20 tonne train carrying 500 million tonnes of coal,,,etc etc etc,,, Yes quite a bit bigger than a mini flywheel yeah??? But again ---> """Horses for Course""" right???
that Jap car "co-relation" or "comparison" (((you stated))) have larger flywheels than minis,,, """Because""" they`re a heavier car!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! &&&& they`re meant for """ROAD_USE""" !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Lightweight race cars (& motorbikes) "LIKE" lightweight flywheels,,,, but they do need zippier gearing & decent revs & "Fanning" of the clutch to get off the line,,, let alone get up hills without having to drop it down a few gears to keep the revs (& torque) up enough to keep it rolling without bogging down..
small capacity """ROAD""" minis are not that,,, road minis weigh approx 700kgs,,, (Wagons are even heavier) Bikes weigh approx 180kgs-ish-----> Big difference!!!!!!!!!!! & they`re meant to be """EASY""" to drive,,, """USER FRIENDLY""" & """FORGIVNG""" For """ROAD_USE"""
"""ROAD""" minis need some Flywheel weight,,, However """RACE""" Minis with 100hp-Plus would rather less flywheel weight (comparitively) for the accelleration factor,,, yes,,, you obviously like a lightweight flywheel in your mini,,, i think we all understand that Ian,,, so do i mate!!!!!!!!!!!!
i was trying to show the "Matching" of parts & the "Balance" of components , """comparitively"""" between """ROAD""" engines & 100hp """RACE""" engines,,, ---> Insert HINT here___>
the title of the thread
if you like to just throw up "FACTS" about """STORED""" energy then please """PLACE IT""" correctly within the appropriate Thread
Or,,, would you rather """EVERYONE""" think that almost no flywheel is better for """EVERY"" """"ROAD""" mini & that the original designers of """EVERY SINGLE ROAD CAR"""" ever made is totally wrong by fitting fairly (comparitively) heavy flywheels ?????
obviously you must be right ... & the whole (World-Wide) motoring industry are totally brain-dead by fitting fairly heavy flywheels """COMPRED TO"""" the std (fairly light weight in comparison) mini flywheel Yeah?????
sorry,,, i` must not have a clue about what i`m talking about then & everyone please forgive my total ignorance of everything rotating... i obviously have no idea & absolutely no experience in this particular subject,,, obviously i`ve NEVER EVER experimented with any of this stuff & My CNC Machined "Light-weight" flywheels that i sell are just a scam
Ian,,, i appaude your persistance & your obvious intellegence,,, but i`m a miss at your "Placement" of said attempt at tuition